Discovered this restaurant because of a vague request from my fiancé: "I want soup right now" And me being the good bean that I am, went on a Google Maps hunt for some soup. Invitations to a diner, Chinese restaurant, or other similar establishments serving soup were declined. "No soup 4 u" I almost said to her, until I stumbled on this restaurant. We walked away vowing to return whenever we were in this crack of Staten Island (I'm from Brooklyn, so I'm allowed to refer to SI like this. Ty). Atmosphere is something akin to a babushka's dining room, really nice. Pictures of people you've never met on the wall and everything. We got the perogies to start...boiled, 5 of them. A preview of things to come. Overall excellent, if you put a gun to my head, I'd say maybe add some milk/butter to the potato mixture inside to make them smoother. Sue me. Pastrami here borders that of the legendary Katz...tender, juicy, well seasoned. It's also under 1/2 the price. She had the Big "Dill" Combo meal (half pastrami sandwich, bowl of Matzo ball soup, coleslaw, pickle) and I had the Pastrami dinner (whole sandwich, fries, coleslaw, pickle). Everything was incredible. She actually offered to share the soup with me because it was that good....true love after all ! Katz charges $29 for a full sandwich...I paid $25 my pastrami dinner. We were taken aback by how quiet it was. No one was in this restaurant...our waiter whispered, so we whispered. She told us it was a hidden gem...and it most certainly is.
Overview
Sandwich and Pickle Modern Delicatessen is a standout destination for food lovers in Staten Island. Located at 1949 Richmond Avenue, this unique delicatessen takes a modern twist on classic sandwich offerings, offering something for everyone. Whether you’re craving a hearty deli sandwich or a light snack, this spot blends traditional flavors with a contemporary vibe, making it a must-visit on the island.
As you walk into Sandwich and Pickle, you’re immediately greeted by a cozy, inviting atmosphere. The warm, friendly service sets the tone for an enjoyable dining experience, whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or settling in for a longer meal with friends or family. The restaurant prides itself on providing quality food in a relaxed setting, making it the perfect place to unwind and enjoy a meal.
One of the standout features of Sandwich and Pickle Modern Delicatessen is their menu, which offers a creative spin on the classic deli. While the traditional sandwich options are available, what truly sets this place apart is their selection of specialty sandwiches and pickles, which are all crafted with fresh, local ingredients. From their signature pastrami on rye to their unique pickled vegetable sides, each dish is made with care and attention to detail.
For those unfamiliar with the place, it’s easy to become a regular just by sampling the various offerings. The deli’s menu is a reflection of its commitment to quality - everything from the bread to the fillings is fresh and flavorful. The sandwiches are generously portioned, and the pickles are an absolute highlight. Tangy, crunchy, and packed with flavor, they’re a perfect complement to the sandwiches. The pickle selection varies, offering a mix of classic dill and creative options that will keep you coming back for more.
A particular favorite among regulars is the “Signature Sandwich,” a unique creation that combines layers of perfectly smoked meats, cheese, and zesty condiments on a fresh, soft roll. It’s an instant hit for anyone looking for a filling and flavorful sandwich. For those with a more adventurous palate, the “Spicy Pickle Delight” offers a kick of heat alongside the crunch of fresh pickles, adding a modern twist to traditional deli flavors.
The experience at Sandwich and Pickle Modern Delicatessen goes beyond just the food. The atmosphere contributes to its charm - casual, yet stylish. The decor is a blend of retro diner aesthetics with a contemporary flair, making it a comfortable spot for a relaxed meal. The staff are friendly and efficient, making sure your visit is smooth from start to finish.
One thing that stands out about this deli is its reputation among locals. Residents of Staten Island have embraced Sandwich and Pickle as a go-to spot for not just its great food but also its consistent quality. Reviews often mention the freshness of the ingredients, the quality of the sandwiches, and the memorable pickle selections. Many patrons note that the deli is perfect for both a quick bite and a leisurely meal, offering the right balance of speed and enjoyment.
The location itself, situated at 1949 Richmond Avenue, is easy to find and accessible. Whether you’re heading there for lunch, a casual dinner, or a weekend treat, you won’t have trouble locating it. Its prime location also makes it a convenient stop for locals who are on the go or want to grab a bite in between errands.
What makes Sandwich and Pickle Modern Delicatessen a standout isn’t just its unique offerings but its dedication to offering an authentic experience. The staff’s knowledge of the menu is evident, and they are happy to recommend a dish based on your preferences. Whether you're a sandwich connoisseur or someone just looking for a hearty meal, there’s something for everyone.
In short, Sandwich and Pickle is more than just another deli. It’s a place where tradition meets modernity, where every sandwich is carefully crafted to bring out the best in classic deli flavors. With its warm ambiance, diverse menu, and friendly staff, it’s easy to see why this Staten Island gem is beloved by so many. Next time you’re in the area, be sure to stop by and experience the best sandwiches and pickles in town.
Good to know
From the business
✓ Identifies as women-ownedService options
✓ Delivery ✓ On-site services ✓ Takeaway ✓ Dine-inHighlights
✓ Fast service ✓ Serves local specialtyPopular for
✓ Breakfast ✓ Lunch ✓ Dinner ✓ Solo diningAccessibility
✓ Wheelchair-accessible entrance ✓ Wheelchair-accessible seating ✓ Wheelchair-accessible toiletOfferings
✓ Alcohol ✓ Beer ✓ Cocktails ✓ Coffee ✓ Comfort food ✓ Quick bite ✓ WineDining options
✓ Breakfast ✓ Brunch ✓ Lunch ✓ Dinner ✓ Catering ✓ Dessert ✓ Seating ✓ Table serviceAmenities
✓ Bar on site ✓ ToiletAtmosphere
✓ CasualCrowd
✓ Family friendlyPlanning
✓ Accepts reservationsPayments
✓ Credit cards ✓ Debit cards ✓ NFC mobile payments ✓ Credit cardsChildren
✓ Good for kids ✓ High chairs ✓ Kids' menuParking
✓ Free parking lot ✓ On-site parking ✓ ParkingPhotos
Location
Reviews
Pastrami could go toe-to-toe with the best. Flavorful soup and sides. Perfect coffee. Generous portions. Great aesthetic. Destination worthy!
Nice cozy place. Food, service and atmosphere all pass the vibe check . They do have a parking lot. It’s very small, so if you plan on going with a big party, I suggest you give them a heads up.
This is a darling of a place, fresh food, kind service and the decor feels like your favorite Aunties house. I love it!!
I ordered latkes for an event, and they did a wonderful job. The online ordering process was very easy, and when I called before pickup to ask if they could package everything in a catering tray, they were happy to accommodate the request without any issues. The food itself was delicious — everyone who tried it enjoyed it very much. I highly recommend this place and will definitely be ordering from them or dining in again in the future.
If you ever find yourself marooned in Staten Island land of forgotten strip malls and rogue pizza parlors and think, “There’s nothing good to eat out here,” punch yourself in the face and then head straight to Sandwich and a Pickle. These folks didn’t just win Best Pastrami Sandwich in Staten Island they earned it. This isn’t some limp, delicounter afterthought. This is pastrami with purpose hand cut, fall apart tender, edged in black pepper and love, stacked like it’s still 1986 and no one’s heard of cholesterol. One bite and you’re somewhere between a Lower East Side Jewish deli and your babushka’s Sunday kitchen in Odessa. It’s a fusion of Jewish and Ukrainian soul food, wrapped in the chic of a brunch spot that somehow doesn’t suck. Grandma’s heart, chef’s brain, and just enough Instagram gloss to make your annoying cousin from Brooklyn say, “Wait, this is in Staten Island?” And then there’s the rug. Yeah. Right in the middle of the dining room. Like something The Dude himself threw down just to tie the whole damn place together. It’s not just kitsch it works. Like having lunch at your one fancy friend’s house. The one with taste, not money. And if you don’t finish with the warmed up chocolate babka, you’re a lost cause. It’s sticky, rich, messy utterly phenomenal. Eat it with your fingers. Lick them clean. That’s what they’re for. Sandwich and a Pickle doesn’t just serve food they serve memory, nostalgia, and a big middle finger to anyone who says Staten Island doesn’t have culinary game. Go. Eat. And bring your appetite and your grandmother’s approval.
Very friendly staff, let me customize my order without hesitation. Has actual brewed iced tea, not from a coffee machine. Definitely get a single latke, they were fresh and crispy. Corned beef and pastrami sammy was great too. More thinly sliced than a Katz for example. Next time need to do afternoon tea.